Seagate Portable External Hard Drive Review (pics)

[Ben Stafford]

There is certainly no dearth of portable storage devices out there. Once you decide about what form factor you want and the capacity you need, then you get to wade through all the different colors and styles that are on the market. Seagate, one of the top hard drive manufacturers has a whole line of Portable External Hard Drives that may suit your needs and your budget. With capacities from 40GB to 160GB and prices from approx $109-$350, you have plenty of choices (of course). In this review, we'll test the Seagate 120GB Portable External Hard Drive.

(view large image)

Drive Specifications

• 5400 RPM, 2.5" hard drive
• 8MB cache
• Powered via USB
• USB 2.0 connection for fast transfers
• 5000 Gs nonoperating shock resistance
• Horizontal dimensions: 1" D x 3.7" W x 5" H
• Weight: 10.3 oz
• One year warranty

Drive Setup and Use

In the box, you'll find the external drive, USB cable, quick start manual, and CD-ROM of software and additional reference material.

(view large image)

The included cable is actually a Y-adapter with a Mini B USB connection into the external drive and two standard USB jacks to plug into your computer. The green connection is labeled: "Data+Power", and the blue one is labeled: "Power Only". First, try plugging in the green one -- if the drive starts up, you're good to go. If not, your USB port may not provide enough power, so insert the blue plug (along with the green one) into another USB port for more juice.

(view large image)

Both Windows and Mac users can use the drive. If you use Windows, you just need Windows XP, Me, 2000, 98SE, and a USB 2.0 port (or USB 1.0 port with third party power supply). If you're a Mac user, you can use the drive with Mac OS 9.x and 10.2.8 or higher with the same USB port requirements as PC users.

Once running, Windows XP, 2000, and Me will automatically detect and install the drivers needed to access the drive. A setup CD is included with the drive in case you need a driver for Windows 98SE.

By default, the drive is formatted with the FAT32 file system. You can reformat as you need. For example, the built-in Windows backup utility will only write backup files of 4GB on FAT32 file system. If you want to do a full backup of your hard drive, you may want to convert the external drive to the NTFS file system.

When the drive is plugged in, you will see a blue LED through the front "grill". During file transfer, the LED gives a little flash to let you know that it's doing its thing.

(view large image)

The 2.5 inch, 5400 RPM drive is amazingly quiet during use. I couldn't hear it over the fans in my Thinkpad T40. For a "real world" test, I copied 4.77GB of mp3 files to the drive and it took 5 minutes and 5 seconds.

For a more objective test, I installed HD Tune and ran it against my internal hard drive and against the Seagate external drive. Results are below.  Yes, the average transfer rate was better and the access time shorter with the external drive than my internal drive!  Me thinks it may be time for a new laptop.

Seagate drive (view large image)

Internal hard drive in my Thinkpad T40 (view large image)

Seagate has included a CD of software and manual materials. They provide some backup software called BounceBack Express which covers the basics of backup software. BounceBack Express estimated that it would take 2 hours and 37 minutes to do a complete backup of the 71.2GB of data that I have on my system. The built-in Windows Backup utility also does a fine job of basic backups. You can get an upgrade to BounceBack Express that helps you set up the external drive to be bootable for disaster recovery purposes and also add some other features.

Conclusion

The Seagate Portable External hard drive is a high-performing solution for some external storage. Use it has a backup device or as an additional hard drive. The 2.5 inch drive and single cable (since it's powered by the USB port) make it portable solution as well. A variety of capacities (from 40GB to 160GB) let you find one that meets your capacity needs and your budget.

Pros

• Compact and portable (compared to other external hard drives)
• Powered over USB connection
• Very quiet operation

Cons

• Maybe a tad too expensive (but you're getting Seagate quality!)
• If you don't need the extra USB plug, you can't get rid of it (I know I'm stretching here)

src="http://www.NotebookReview.com/assets/38142bargainspots.JavaScript">

src="http://www.NotebookReview.com/assets/41954bargainspots.JavaScript">

src="http://www.NotebookReview.com/assets/41955bargainspots.JavaScript">

src="http://www.NotebookReview.com/assets/41956bargainspots.JavaScript">

[Notebook Solutions]

Great review Ben...

I am still amazed that they can make external hard disk of 120 gb, but no extern videocard of 128 mb But that is my way of thinking, I am more of a gamer

Charlie-Peru

[Andrew Baxter]

thanks for the review Ben, this drive seems like it's a lot more bang for the buck than the Pocket drive Brian reviewed last week, it was only 5GB and cost $80 whereas you can get 60GB for $120 here. Was this one a whole lot bigger or weigh more?

Here's the link and image for the HD I refer to

http://www.notebookreview.com/default.asp?newsID=2882

[Brian]

I'll see if we can get a side by side Monday.

[nathanhuth]

Thanks for the review Ben, great stuff. I would like to know if I could take the drive out and put it in my laptop as my main HD after mirroring my undersized drive to it?

[Ben Stafford]

Not sure if you'll be able to take the drive out in a feasible way. The case looks like it's riveted together, so you'd have to drill out the rivets. After that, I'm not sure what you'd find.

Like Brian mentioned, we'll try to get some side by side image action, but looking at the specs:

weight: 10.3 oz vs 2.2 oz
size: 1" D x 3.7" W x 5" H (small paperback) Vs. 0.71" H x 3.03" D (smaller than a hockey puck)

[Irishcanuck]

How does it run heat wise? Like would it be safe to have tucked away somewhere, or would it be better to have it in an open space besides your laptop?

[Charles P. Jefferies]

Nice job Ben, superb pictures.

I actually made my own external - took the 80GB 5400RPM out of my (er, two laptops ago), bought a Vantec NexStar enclosure off of Newegg for $17, and stuck it in. Works very well.

Chaz

[titaniummd]

What is the effect of the drive on battery life? With 2 USB attachments it must be causing some significant drain when compared to a single USB attachment.

[gilo]

I'd like to add one BIG con :

only 1 year warranty versus buying any 5400 drive ( including Segate ) in the market and putting it in a 2.5 enclosure getting a 3-5 year warranty .