Quantcast NOW AVAILABLE - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D - Page 19

View Poll Results: Did you purchase a shiny new ENVY 15 and/or ENVY 17?

Voters
214. You may not vote on this poll
  • Yes, purchased the ENVY 15!

    132 61.68%
  • Yes, purchased the ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D!

    84 39.25%
Multiple Choice Poll.
+ Reply to Thread
Page 19 of 401 FirstFirst ... 91516171819202122232969119 ... LastLast
Results 181 to 190 of 4002
  1. #181
    Notebook Consultant
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    287
    Rep Power
    9

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    Quote Originally Posted by gcrussell1 View Post
    The 14 runs very cool even under heavy loads - judging by the size of the DV6T and the fact that I've not heard anything about those overheating, I would say that the Envy 14 could probably handle a 6770 just dandy. Why go to all the trouble to design a machine that has great cooling if you're just going to put underpowered components in it?
    Maybe it was some sort of space or power concern then.
    ENVY 15 Core i7-2860QM | 8GB RAM | 750GB Hybrid HD | Radeon 7690M

  2. #182
    Notebook Evangelist
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Northeast Ohio
    Posts
    619
    Rep Power
    14

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    Quote Originally Posted by TheAtreidesHawk View Post
    And in the meantime get what? A small laptop sure but I know by the time I buy something that satisfies my needs I'll be hitting $1,000+ easily when I really should limit my budget to just $500...

    Sigh decisions decisions....
    Why spend $500+ on a laptop just to 'hold you over' till the laptop you really want comes out? that seems like a massive waste of money and you'll end up spending double what you wanted to spend to begin with.

    Quote Originally Posted by gcrussell1 View Post
    The 14 runs very cool even under heavy loads - judging by the size of the DV6T and the fact that I've not heard anything about those overheating, I would say that the Envy 14 could probably handle a 6770 just dandy. Why go to all the trouble to design a machine that has great cooling if you're just going to put underpowered components in it?
    That's the point though, it's not 'underpowered' components so much as over-cooled components, you want your laptop to stay cool under heavy heat, I've heard complaints about the Envy 14 getting hot with the quad core in it, I don't know if those were resolved but there were definitely some heat issues going on with the quad. If it can handle the 6630 very well then why are you complaining? You know what's coming in it to begin with and if it can cool properly then that's all you can ask for. I'd be ecstatic if my laptop never got warm no matter where I put it.

    Quote Originally Posted by wetwillycf View Post
    Maybe it was some sort of space or power concern then.
    Or they just wanted to keep the laptop cool period, plus it probably would have forced them to have a larger power brick.
    RIP: Dell M1210 6 years. Dell Inspiron 6400 6 years.
    Still running: Dell Inspiron 1520, 5 years.
    Returned Laptop: Asus G53SW.
    Currently musing: XPS 13, XPS 14, UX31A Haswell Refreshes

    If you want to sound intelligent and have people listen to you, 'u' is not acceptable speech, typing the full word out makes you look more intelligent and takes an extra half second.

  3. #183
    Just this guy, you know?
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Wuhan, China
    Posts
    2,138
    Rep Power
    24

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    Quote Originally Posted by Netherwind View Post
    That's the point though, it's not 'underpowered' components so much as over-cooled components, you want your laptop to stay cool under heavy heat, I've heard complaints about the Envy 14 getting hot with the quad core in it, I don't know if those were resolved but there were definitely some heat issues going on with the quad. If it can handle the 6630 very well then why are you complaining? You know what's coming in it to begin with and if it can cool properly then that's all you can ask for. I'd be ecstatic if my laptop never got warm no matter where I put it.
    I don't know about the quad core issue you're talking about, so I can't comment on that. My issue is that an Envy 14 with a good screen and an upper-mid-range GPU like the 6770m, which I believe it could support just fine, would be exactly what I want in a laptop, whereas the old generation had a gimped mid-range card and the current generation has a lower-mid-range card and a rubbish screen. I'm complaining because HP could create essentially the perfect laptop for someone who wants a mobile laptop with a good screen, good build quality, good battery life, and good gaming power, but instead they chose to fall short on one or more of those expectations. If they reduced the bezel size so the notebook was closer in size to a typical 14" instead of being notably larger in the horizontal dimensions then the weaker GPUs would be justified, but considering that the 14's almost as big as some 15.6" laptops, they should have at least offered a better GPU as an upgrade, if not standard.
    "Manny Calavera" (Now my wife's) - Envy 14 - i5-450m, 5650M, 8GB DDR3, 160GB Intel X-25M SSD, Win 7 HP x64, Radiance Display, Slice Battery
    "Grim Fandango" - Lenovo Yoga 2 Pro - Silver - i5-4200UM - 8GB DDR3, 256GB SSD, Win 8.1, 3200x1800
    Desktop - i5-3450, MSI Radeon HD7850 Hawk, 8 GB Kingston HyperX Blue, 128GB Samsung 830 SSD, 2TB WD Caviar Green HDD, CoolerMaster Elite 120 ITX case, AsRock H77M-ITX, CoolerMaster Silent M2 420W, Samsung Blu-Ray reader

  4. #184
    Notebook Evangelist
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Northeast Ohio
    Posts
    619
    Rep Power
    14

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    Quote Originally Posted by gcrussell1 View Post
    I don't know about the quad core issue you're talking about, so I can't comment on that. My issue is that an Envy 14 with a good screen and an upper-mid-range GPU like the 6770m, which I believe it could support just fine, would be exactly what I want in a laptop, whereas the old generation had a gimped mid-range card and the current generation has a lower-mid-range card and a rubbish screen. I'm complaining because HP could create essentially the perfect laptop for someone who wants a mobile laptop with a good screen, good build quality, good battery life, and good gaming power, but instead they chose to fall short on one or more of those expectations. If they reduced the bezel size so the notebook was closer in size to a typical 14" instead of being notably larger in the horizontal dimensions then the weaker GPUs would be justified, but considering that the 14's almost as big as some 15.6" laptops, they should have at least offered a better GPU as an upgrade, if not standard.
    Why do you say that the 15.6" isn't portable? I'm just curious, I have a skewed view on portability because I'm tall, and I'm sure they could put a higher powered card in there, but I'm sure there's other design issues they didn't want to forfeit in order to use the higher powered card (ala 6770m). Plus that would cannibalize dv6t sales. The notebook can't be closer to a typical 14 due to the size of the screen, if they were to drop .4" and go to 14.1" screen then they could probably source the part easier and be able to provide an actual 14" that can game. It seems all of the 'gaming grade' 14" laptops are really closer to 15's in size, just with a smaller screen and lower resolution, using the m14x for example, it's nearly the size of smaller 15's.
    RIP: Dell M1210 6 years. Dell Inspiron 6400 6 years.
    Still running: Dell Inspiron 1520, 5 years.
    Returned Laptop: Asus G53SW.
    Currently musing: XPS 13, XPS 14, UX31A Haswell Refreshes

    If you want to sound intelligent and have people listen to you, 'u' is not acceptable speech, typing the full word out makes you look more intelligent and takes an extra half second.

  5. #185
    Just this guy, you know?
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Wuhan, China
    Posts
    2,138
    Rep Power
    24

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    Quote Originally Posted by Netherwind View Post
    Why do you say that the 15.6" isn't portable? I'm just curious, I have a skewed view on portability because I'm tall, and I'm sure they could put a higher powered card in there, but I'm sure there's other design issues they didn't want to forfeit in order to use the higher powered card (ala 6770m). Plus that would cannibalize dv6t sales. The notebook can't be closer to a typical 14 due to the size of the screen, if they were to drop .4" and go to 14.1" screen then they could probably source the part easier and be able to provide an actual 14" that can game. It seems all of the 'gaming grade' 14" laptops are really closer to 15's in size, just with a smaller screen and lower resolution, using the m14x for example, it's nearly the size of smaller 15's.
    I'm 6'3" and a pretty fit 220 lbs, and I think that anything larger than a large 14" is borderline for portability, especially if you have to carry an adapter as well. Then again, I bike a lot and carry a messenger bag rather than a backpack, so my views on portability are skewed by the viability of carrying a laptop in that particular situation. Still, I think a lot of people would agree that 15.6" is bigger than you want for a laptop you'll carry around regularly.

    As for cannibalizing dv6t sales, the Envy is supposed to be a premium line and as such should provide a higher profit margin as a prestige product. Instead of Envy 14's cannibalizing dv6t sales, the opposite has been happening - the dv6t has proven a more-than-ample competitor to the Envy 14 for a great deal of the Envy 14's run - it provides more power for less money in a slightly bigger and less-attractive package, and I'd say that the proportion of potential Envy 14 buyers who ended up going for the dv6t as a direct alternative would add up to a rather significant number of sales.

    That's one reason to be skeptical of the Envy 15 - if it uses a 7690 it'll have less GPU power than the current-gen dv6t for way more money (and that 7690 will not be an adequate 1080p performer for most modern games). If the 15's Radiance screen is really IPS that will be a big selling point, but the slick looks and quality screen will come at a huge price disadvantage compared to the dv6t for similar performance, especially if the screen is an upgrade.
    "Manny Calavera" (Now my wife's) - Envy 14 - i5-450m, 5650M, 8GB DDR3, 160GB Intel X-25M SSD, Win 7 HP x64, Radiance Display, Slice Battery
    "Grim Fandango" - Lenovo Yoga 2 Pro - Silver - i5-4200UM - 8GB DDR3, 256GB SSD, Win 8.1, 3200x1800
    Desktop - i5-3450, MSI Radeon HD7850 Hawk, 8 GB Kingston HyperX Blue, 128GB Samsung 830 SSD, 2TB WD Caviar Green HDD, CoolerMaster Elite 120 ITX case, AsRock H77M-ITX, CoolerMaster Silent M2 420W, Samsung Blu-Ray reader

  6. #186
    Notebook Evangelist
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    New York State
    Posts
    532
    Rep Power
    17

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    Do we know yet whether the 3D will finally output 3D to external monitors/TVs? That would get me more interested.
    ----------------------
    Sold:
    HP Envy 17 3D
    1080P LCD screen
    2 x 1TB HDD
    8GB RAM
    Blu-ray Reader/Burner
    -----
    Current:
    HP Envy 17 3D SB 2011
    128GB SSD + 2 x 1TB HDD
    8GB RAM
    Blu-ray reader

  7. #187
    Notebook Consultant
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    287
    Rep Power
    9

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    In the short few months I've been on this board, I've seen a lot of people who have really been unhappy with the choice of 6630M.

    I love my Envy 14, and yeah, I'd prefer something beefier. But I've got to say that I don't think HP deliberately tried to screw people by forcing them to choose a weak (though the evolutionary chip of the 5650, so technically, it's the same level as the first one?) GPU. I believe that there's a reason HP put the 6630M in instead of something better. It could be power-related. Perhaps there's a mobo design consideration that differs between the 6630 and 6770, and it was the same with the 5650. That could mean that they didn't want to re-engineer the mobo. Perhaps they had a particular goal for battery life with Radeon enabled. Or maybe, just maybe, they listened to all the heat complaints of Envys past, and thought you know, the way the airflow/heat dissipation is with the current design, the 6630 will be cool but the 6770 might be warm.

    All I know is maybe the 6630 was a disappointing choice when the 2nd gen was released, but for people to say HP was lazy or terrible at engineering or something, I think they probably had a bunch of valid/logical reasons behind why they chose the 6630. I'm not saying they were good, as neither me nor anybody else were there when they chose. What I'm saying is that though the Envy is far from perfect, being able to get an Envy 14 for $800 is a pretty dang good price. And if being able to get one at that price meant that (as seeing the 2nd gen is not going to be a long-term design) they didn't want to re-engineer the design to accommodate some sort of difference that we aren't privy to in order to use a stronger GPU, well, from a business perspective, perhaps they made the right choice if the lower price meant they sold 1500 more than they would have.

    And now we have these (potentially) sweet new 15 and 17 models to choose from. 14" laptops with real graphics performance are pretty uncommon. If you want portability, get an ultrabook. If you want performance, get a gaming laptop. If you want both, save your money and get a Vaio Z. Sadly, the perfect laptop doesn't exist yet at a price normal people can afford.

    I also think that any sort of benchmarks we see of this 7690 prior to release should be considered preliminary. I wouldn't get too bent out of shape either way just yet.
    ENVY 15 Core i7-2860QM | 8GB RAM | 750GB Hybrid HD | Radeon 7690M

  8. #188
    Just this guy, you know?
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Wuhan, China
    Posts
    2,138
    Rep Power
    24

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    Quote Originally Posted by wetwillycf View Post
    In the short few months I've been on this board, I've seen a lot of people who have really been unhappy with the choice of 6630M.

    I love my Envy 14, and yeah, I'd prefer something beefier. But I've got to say that I don't think HP deliberately tried to screw people by forcing them to choose a weak (though the evolutionary chip of the 5650, so technically, it's the same level as the first one?) GPU. I believe that there's a reason HP put the 6630M in instead of something better. It could be power-related. Perhaps there's a mobo design consideration that differs between the 6630 and 6770, and it was the same with the 5650. That could mean that they didn't want to re-engineer the mobo. Perhaps they had a particular goal for battery life with Radeon enabled. Or maybe, just maybe, they listened to all the heat complaints of Envys past, and thought you know, the way the airflow/heat dissipation is with the current design, the 6630 will be cool but the 6770 might be warm.

    All I know is maybe the 6630 was a disappointing choice when the 2nd gen was released, but for people to say HP was lazy or terrible at engineering or something, I think they probably had a bunch of valid/logical reasons behind why they chose the 6630. I'm not saying they were good, as neither me nor anybody else were there when they chose. What I'm saying is that though the Envy is far from perfect, being able to get an Envy 14 for $800 is a pretty dang good price. And if being able to get one at that price meant that (as seeing the 2nd gen is not going to be a long-term design) they didn't want to re-engineer the design to accommodate some sort of difference that we aren't privy to in order to use a stronger GPU, well, from a business perspective, perhaps they made the right choice if the lower price meant they sold 1500 more than they would have.

    And now we have these (potentially) sweet new 15 and 17 models to choose from. 14" laptops with real graphics performance are pretty uncommon. If you want portability, get an ultrabook. If you want performance, get a gaming laptop. If you want both, save your money and get a Vaio Z. Sadly, the perfect laptop doesn't exist yet at a price normal people can afford.

    I also think that any sort of benchmarks we see of this 7690 prior to release should be considered preliminary. I wouldn't get too bent out of shape either way just yet.
    The bottom line is that many of us saw the Envy 14 as a chance to create a unique combination of power and portability. Something that might not be as powerful as a bigger laptop or as portable as a smaller one, but that nevertheless could reach a hitherto unprecedented amount of both. In other words, we were hoping for something that blurred the lines of power and portability, and many of us are of the opinion that HP was too conservative in their design to deliver what we wanted.

    Don't get me wrong, even a proper 5650m would have been acceptable in the first generation, but it was gimped to 450 mHz clocks instead of the standard 550 mHz. Then they upgrade to the 6630m, which is, to be fair, the direct successor to the Envy 14's 5650m, but the nomenclature taking a step backward from 650 to 630 just serves to further highlight that it's a gimped GPU, which doesn't sit well with many people who are out to buy a "premium" product.
    "Manny Calavera" (Now my wife's) - Envy 14 - i5-450m, 5650M, 8GB DDR3, 160GB Intel X-25M SSD, Win 7 HP x64, Radiance Display, Slice Battery
    "Grim Fandango" - Lenovo Yoga 2 Pro - Silver - i5-4200UM - 8GB DDR3, 256GB SSD, Win 8.1, 3200x1800
    Desktop - i5-3450, MSI Radeon HD7850 Hawk, 8 GB Kingston HyperX Blue, 128GB Samsung 830 SSD, 2TB WD Caviar Green HDD, CoolerMaster Elite 120 ITX case, AsRock H77M-ITX, CoolerMaster Silent M2 420W, Samsung Blu-Ray reader

  9. #189
    Notebook Evangelist
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Northeast Ohio
    Posts
    619
    Rep Power
    14

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    Quote Originally Posted by gcrussell1 View Post
    I'm 6'3" and a pretty fit 220 lbs, and I think that anything larger than a large 14" is borderline for portability, especially if you have to carry an adapter as well. Then again, I bike a lot and carry a messenger bag rather than a backpack, so my views on portability are skewed by the viability of carrying a laptop in that particular situation. Still, I think a lot of people would agree that 15.6" is bigger than you want for a laptop you'll carry around regularly.

    As for cannibalizing dv6t sales, the Envy is supposed to be a premium line and as such should provide a higher profit margin as a prestige product. Instead of Envy 14's cannibalizing dv6t sales, the opposite has been happening - the dv6t has proven a more-than-ample competitor to the Envy 14 for a great deal of the Envy 14's run - it provides more power for less money in a slightly bigger and less-attractive package, and I'd say that the proportion of potential Envy 14 buyers who ended up going for the dv6t as a direct alternative would add up to a rather significant number of sales.

    That's one reason to be skeptical of the Envy 15 - if it uses a 7690 it'll have less GPU power than the current-gen dv6t for way more money (and that 7690 will not be an adequate 1080p performer for most modern games). If the 15's Radiance screen is really IPS that will be a big selling point, but the slick looks and quality screen will come at a huge price disadvantage compared to the dv6t for similar performance, especially if the screen is an upgrade.
    I'm 6'7 and 280 Anyway, the 7690 is an absolute brand new chip, the people crying rebrand have no idea what they're talking about. It is a 28nm chip based on their GCN architecture. If performance is really that dismal as the benchmarks showed it's quite possible that performance can heavily improve given time. I'd be very surprised if the 7690 is less powerful than the outgoing 5830. The IPS screen is the most important selling point I do agree, and I believe the 7690 will be an adequate performer for 1080p for modern games, not on ultra/high but medium it should do fine. I have a Targus XL backpack that I carry around all the time and I find my current 15.4" to be small, if not adequate, I used to use a 12.1" m1210 and it was just too small for my large hands, 15.6" is a pretty good size and personally I'd be okay with a 16" if it meant better cooling and better power. Don't judge a book by it's cover and we'll see the real performance of the Envy 15 once it's released with WHQL Drivers.
    RIP: Dell M1210 6 years. Dell Inspiron 6400 6 years.
    Still running: Dell Inspiron 1520, 5 years.
    Returned Laptop: Asus G53SW.
    Currently musing: XPS 13, XPS 14, UX31A Haswell Refreshes

    If you want to sound intelligent and have people listen to you, 'u' is not acceptable speech, typing the full word out makes you look more intelligent and takes an extra half second.

  10. #190
    Notebook Deity
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    1,940
    Rep Power
    23

    Default Re: COMING DECEMBER 7 - Updated ENVY 15, ENVY 17 / ENVY 17 3D

    I'm really not sure why people are obsessing over this whole 14' Envy. 14....15 is it really that big a difference? Anyways I'm just gonna go with my gut and get the new Envy to replace this horrible replacement I'm currently suffering with.

    Yes Ivy Bridge will be out but I've already got everything I wanted to put into the Envy and I'm gonna keep it for 5 years at the very least so by that time I'm sure something amazing will be out.

 

 

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:01 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2
Copyright © 2014 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.1